Tarallo's Pizzeria Restaurant Read Our Reviews feat-8

Customer reviews

**** (4 stars)

It's hard not to get nostalgic about a family-operated place like this. When I was little, it used to be in the corner space that now houses those short-lived kid party places. It was a focal point for all the kids for the sesame crust pizza and the Mortal Kombat arcade. Now, it's been downsized but the pizza is still the same great taste I remember. I also highly recommend their garlic knots which are easily the best in the county. Everyone makes them so dry compared to theirs.

Pro tip: If you have a summer party, you can rent an Italian ice cart from them for a reasonable price.

- James D.


***** (5 stars)

I've been going to this pizza place for the past 15 years at least.  All the workers there are so friendly and the sesame crust is amazing. One of the best pizza places around.  

- Meghan M.


***** (5 stars)

Excellent pizza...I have been coming here since I was a kid. Get the sesame crust, its awesome!

- Tommy H.


**** (4 stars)

Very good pizza. Sesame crust is delicious. So are those garlic nuts. The staff is super friendly and the location is convenient since close to lirr.

- Sue P.


****(4 stars)

Nice old school neighborhood place. I've been there a few times. I think their pizza is better than most of the area places. The sesame seed crust on the pie is a nice touch. I will try some other menu items but obviously pizzerias live and die on how good the pizza is. The staff is very nice too.  You get a laid back, family feel from the place. Definitely a place I can see becoming a regular customer.

- Vin G.


**** (4 stars)

Great neighborhood pizzeria with very friendly staff! Best sesame crusted pizza I've had. The owner is a great guy and very personable with customers and remembers you on a first name basis.

-Ingrid S.


**** (4 stars)

I have distinct memories from here. So close to both the Manor and Seaford Middle School, every school function or classroom event that had pizza... was from Tarallo's. I knew this because of their sesame seed crust. This was also a popular place for kids to hangout, especially after school. I've had their pizza many times and was never disappointed. Great spot that's been around forever.

~Katie H.


**** (4 stars)

Tarallo's is a good, consistent neighborhood pizza place. Sesame crust on pizza as standard and chicken parm hero's that are toasted just right. For some reason pizza from here goes down like water. Before you know it, you have eaten 3 or 4 slices.

~Steve B.



Gluten Free options

Signature Mini Pies

Our signature mini pies are perfect for lunch and dinner and come in all of your favorites.

Appetizer Sampler  

Hot wings, mozzarella sticks and baked clams

Only $9.75

CTA feat-4